Digital Minimalism: A Constructive Argument

Social Connectivity

While digital minimalism emphasizes reducing screen time, many find value in staying connected through social media. These platforms can help maintain relationships, particularly during times of social distancing or for those with limited physical mobility.

Digital minimalism has its detractors; the tech giants probably aren't big fans of this concept, given that their companies thrive on capturing your attention. They would argue that social media is a great way to prevent social isolation and to stay connected to loved ones and communities. For instance, Facebook launched a marketing campaign in late 2020 promoting their updated Facebook Groups features. This was timely, coinciding with lockdowns, as people sought ways to stay connected with others and their hobbies. The campaign was successful, with over 1.4 billion people using Facebook Groups in October 2020 alone (Hutchinson). The dark side of this is stated best by Daniel Newman, a principal analyst at Futurum Research:

"The growth in focus on groups is strategic and well-designed. It’s keeping users on the site longer and providing rich, harvestable data for Facebook and its advertisers" (qtd. in Rodriguez).

Many users are willing to trade their data for community connection. However, this trade-off raises concerns, especially with the growing issue of data breaches. In 2024 alone, there were at least 1 billion stolen records from various companies, including healthcare and telecommunications (Whittaker). No company can guarantee the perpetual safety of your data.

Economic Impact

The economic impact of more people going tech-free is concerning for freelancers who rely on finding business opportunities through various online sources. Fewer people being connected means less income for these independent workers. It could also harm the corporations that employ thousands of us. Imagine if companies had no way to advertise their products. Fewer products sold would mean fewer jobs created and maintained. However, the probability of such widespread tech abandonment is extremely low; it would require either a massive societal shift or an unlikely event like a solar flare (🌞 lol) for such a scenario to become a reality.

The idea that one should apply for jobs in person, as our parents might have suggested, is largely outdated. Platforms like LinkedIn enable connections with industry leaders, which are crucial for career advancement. It’s challenging enough to secure a job; attempting to do so without the internet would be far more difficult. However, it’s worth noting that LinkedIn, while designed to assist in job searching, can be just as addictive and demoralizing as other social media platforms.

Industries depend on digital technologies for operational efficiency and management. Tools like cloud-based project management systems are essential for maintaining a competitive edge. A shift away from these tools could impact both efficiency and market position. Nevertheless, ask any employee whether the software and programs they use daily help or hinder their productivity, and you’ll likely hear that they find it more of a hindrance.

Access to Information

The internet provides immediate access to a vast array of information, which is crucial for staying informed and continuing education. Limiting digital use might restrict access to important news and educational resources. Attending college as an adult with a full-time job would be incredibly difficult if you couldn't attend online classes. Digital platforms also offer extensive resources for academic research and professional development. You don't even have to physically go to the library now; renting e-books and audiobooks via the Libby app has made this process streamlined.

Healthcare

Telehealth emerged as one of the most beneficial developments during the COVID-19 pandemic. It became mainstream, and health insurance companies adapted by making telehealth a viable option. Instant access to health information is invaluable, provided that the healthcare providers can keep this information secure. Telehealth has transformed the lives of many, particularly those with disabilities. Philip Powell, the NTIA’s (National Telecommunications and Information Administration) Federal Program Officer for Arkansas and Oklahoma, discusses its impact on his life:

"I am Deaf and have first-hand experience with how high-speed Internet assists the disability community. I visit my audiologist annually to ensure my cochlear implant is working properly. I’ve used the same doctor in Alabama for over two decades. She can now make adjustments remotely and conduct the visit via high-speed Internet. I no longer have to take two or three days away from work and family to drive to Alabama for one visit" (Powell).

This is a testament to the positive side of the internet.